The Good Order
I get excited about Robert’s Rules of Order. I know how that sounds. But across forty-five years as a lawyer for communities, a term in the Oregon Legislature, and a good many years as a husband and father, I’ve watched one thing prove true over and over: a fair structure is how people who don’t agree manage to build something together — without tearing apart, and without being held together by force. Good process isn’t the cage around freedom. It’s the trellis that lets a community grow.
This publication is about that conviction at every scale — a family deciding together, a congregation giving its members a voice, a club’s bylaws, a county, a nation. Some weeks I’ll write about a state’s voting method; some weeks about how a meeting is run. From the outside it looks like a strange range of subjects. It isn’t. It’s one subject: how communities of any size live together in their differences.
I come to it as someone who believes structure is a moral matter — that the order we build either serves the growth and dignity of everyone under it, or the dominance of some over others. That difference is most of what I write about, and it’s why the word that matters in the name is the first one. Not order. Good order.
The practice I’ll keep asking of you, and of myself, is a kind of civic attention: noticing the structures we already live inside, most of which we never chose, and asking honestly whether they serve everyone or only some.
Beneath all of it is a single conviction: that the purpose of any good order — in a family, a congregation, or a republic — is to build the structure within which we are free to help one another thrive. Stephen Covey, at whose feet I was lucky to sit years ago, liked to say that love is a verb. I would only add that love, to reach past a single heart, needs a structure to travel through — and that structure is what I call good order.
Subscribe and these essays come straight to your inbox, free. If a piece makes you want to argue, send it to someone who’ll argue back. That’s the point.
— Rich Vial, writing from Scholls, Oregon